Today I was reminded (a couple of times, actually) of a moment with my home teachers the spring after Paul died. (I think it was spring, I’m not sure really, that “widow-fog” is real for that first two years or so.) I was serving as a chorister in primary, and John and Jake were both primary teachers at the time. They saw I was a having kind of a rough day (more aloof than usual, caught up in my own thoughts, even a little teary) and already had a visit scheduled that afternoon after church. When they came to my little house, they asked how I was. I remember that I replied weakly, “Fine,” and then, after seeing their looks, “I will be fine, I know it. I will be okay, eventually, so I’m really okay now.” Like I was trying to reassure them (as I was constantly doing then to everyone) not to worry about me. And then Jake Wheadon said, “That’s great, and I’m glad you’re fine, but you know, it’d totally be okay if you were NOT fine. You are dealing with something really big and heavy and crappy and if you’re not okay, it wouldn’t make you any less awesome of a person just because you’re struggling. We would still like you and wouldn’t think any less of you because this is hard.” And I promptly broke down in tears--not because of the dark thoughts that had been plaguing me all day in my grief, but because the words he said were words I don’t recall ever hearing before, and words I desperately needed to hear then (and think about often since).
Of course we all know that everyone else is imperfect and blah blah blah but it’s so rare that we acknowledge and embrace so vocally that imperfection. Especially in the church, when we know we are commanded to “be ye perfect.” More than that, though, I have been very blessed throughout my life in a great many things. I’ve been a pretty quick study with a curious mind, have been told my whole life how good I am at this or that, which I know is better than being bullied, belittled, or condescended to. I’ve been asked more times than I can count, “Is there anything you can’t do?” or told how “strong” I’ve been or how “sweet” I am or have been pooh-poohed as simply being “modest” when I try to point out the many things I’m only mediocre or even incredibly bad at. It’s maddening, actually. Even thinking about it makes me shake a little with frustration.
Because however well-intentioned, however rooted in love these comments might have been, all the cumulative effect has been is to make me feel like I MUST be good at everything and stronger and smarter and braver than I really am, and must maintain the illusion that I am holding it all together, because if I don’t then people will think less of me/won’t like me/will be disappointed/whatever. I’m afraid to try things unless I know I’ll be good at them. The truth is, I’ve grown up into an exhausted and scared and frustrated person, especially when people compliment me or deny me the basic right of self-awareness. Because I know the truth about myself, and yes, sometimes I’m hard on myself or can be self-deprecating, but often I’m realistic in my intimate vision of who I really am. And clearly “they” aren’t. And if they did, the idea they unconsciously put out there is that they know me better than I know myself, or that only the people and things of worth are worth talking to/about. So I have two choices: be isolated further by my truth or try to live up to theirs. And it probably sounds ridiculous, and I know it could be so much worse, but sometimes praise is a spirit-killer, too. Sometimes the things we say to encourage the people we love end up doing a lot of damage and make them scared to try. I want to say to them sometimes:
Just let me be human. Let me acknowledge my vulnerabilities and weaknesses in front of you without you (in misguided kindness) trying to contradict me. I’m a little broken, and the faster I see you allowing for that and loving me anyway, the sooner I can let my walls down and the happier we both will be. If I say I’m overweight and trying to work on that, don’t tell me I’m not. I am. It’s only “bad” if you equate weight with worth. Same with prettiness. I know I’m not pretty, and I’m okay with that, because beautiful is not the same thing as worthy. I am terrible at some things, only average at a great many things, and some of my talents I do have to work REALLY hard for, and that’s all okay, isn’t it? Don’t try to make me feel better by invalidating the things I know about myself, because then I stop trusting you with all the other things, too. How about just saying, “I know. But I admire how hard you work at this,” or “I’m glad you can enjoy things you’re not so good at, at least,” or “How great is it that people have their whole lives--eternity even--to grow?” or just “I love you anyway,” and share the “realness” of your own life with me so I know I’m not alone? I’m not saying we excuse sin or indulge self-harm. How about we let each other be a little broken and tell each other, “It’s okay, I’m broken, too, you’re still important to me, I still like you, maybe even a little more now because I see all the things you’re not and that makes the things you ARE all the more remarkable to me.”
*Sigh.* If only.
I promise I will try to be better about this, too. I know our society has us constantly putting our best sides out there for all to see, and hiding anything that isn't Pinterest-perfect. I know, too, in our daily interactions, we try to be kind by ignoring or even outright denying the imperfection of others. When they say their chicken was a little dry, we tell them not to be so hard on themselves, they're great cooks and that it was delicious. When they share that they are struggling with their marriage or children, we reassure them that they are wonderful wives/mothers. We all do it. It's what we are trained and encouraged and expected to do. We are uncomfortable with anything else. But what if it is doing more harm than good? I'm not saying to walk around and point out other people's imperfections or to be unkind. If you know me, you know kindness is one of the MOST IMPORTANT things to me, and calling out other people unnecessarily is neither kind nor productive. I just think true kindness comes from a true understanding and pure love with no expectations and a focus on the other person's comfort instead of our own.
















